In lenin, stalin, and hitler, acclaimed historian robert gellately focuses on the dominant powers of the time, the soviet union and nazi germany, but also analyzes the catastrophe of those years in an effort to uncover its. Stalin, hitler and the temptations of totalitarianism the. He read history and marxist philosophy, he read popularized science, he also read fiction voraciously. The age of social catastrophe, is that the advent of lenin and the bolshevik party to power in russia in 1917 directly led to the nightmare societies of germany and the soviet union in. Joseph stalin, leader of the soviet union 18781953 youtube. Under lenins leadership, the new soviet state faced critical challenges which threatened its survival. One of the most influential of the postsoviet books was the princeton historian stephen kotkins magnetic mountain. Lenin and stalin happen to be the most prominent and influential leaders of modern soviet union.
Sep 02, 2009 helen rappaports top 10 books on lenin. His real name was dzhugashvili also spelled dzugashvili or djugashvili. On lenin s death, stalin, kamenev, and grigori zinoviev formed a triumvirate of successors allied against trotsky, who was a strong contender to replace lenin. Of the many books that deal with these two worldchanging figures, hitler and stalin. List of books and articles about joseph stalin online. Stalinism as a civilization 1995, a study of the steel city of. An oxfordtrained historian who worked for the british information research department producing antisoviet material and later as one of margaret thatchers advisers, conquest is best known for.
The age of social catastrophe ebook written by robert gellately. Oct 18, 2017 of the many books that deal with these two worldchanging figures, hitler and stalin. Stalin s purge of the 1930s 1968, where marx went wrong 1970, lenin 1972, stalin. He received an ma in modern languages from the university of cambridge and an ma and a phd in government from the university of essex. Parallel lives, by the british historian alan bullock, published in 1992, is. Joseph stalin was a georgian born student radical who became a member and eventually a leader of the bolshevik faction of the russian social democratic labour party. Staggeringly wide in scope note the 100page bibliography, this work meticulously examines the structural forces that brought down one autocratic. He served as the general secretary of the central committee of the communist party of the soviet union from 1922 until his death in 1953.
Yet stalin was also worse, because his regime killed far, far more. Lenin and stalin both had ideas of how books should be used in the soviet union and these ideas are contrary to how we perceive the use of books today. Robert conquest was one of the 20th centurys bestknown historians specialising in russia. Stalins elevation as lenins general secretary in 1922 both spurred stalins own personal dictatorship and aroused alarme. Whatever stalin perfected was rooted in the leninist system. How lenins love of literature shaped the russian revolution. As bolshevik ideas and tactics return to world politics, victor sebestyen focuses our attention on man who invented them. Lenin and stalin as mass leaders marxists internet archive. Yet stalin was also worse, because his regime killed far, far more peopletens of millions, it was. Stalin, like lenin, is distinguished by high ability as a mass activizer. Stalins body removed from lenins tomb after his death people acknowledged stalins atrocities. The central thesis of robert gellatelys work lenin, stalin, and hitler. Trotskys stalin is unique in marxist literature in that it attempts to explain some of the most decisive events of the 20th century, not just in terms of epochmaking economic and social transformations, but in the individual psychology of one of the protagonists in a great historical drama. He is a russian historian and political commentator.
Lenins terror abebooks abebooks shop for books, art. Lenin had only seven years in power while stalin had 30. In the years following the death of vladimir lenin, he rose to become dictator. The age of social catastrophe, is that the advent of lenin and the bolshevik party to power in russia in 1917 directly led to the nightmare societies of germany and the soviet union in the 1920s, 30s, and beyond. Terrorism, war, empire, love, rebellion is published next month by verso. Nov 11, 2009 a bold new accounting of the great social and political upheavals that enveloped europe between 1914 and 1945from the russian revolution through the second world war. A woman is flanked by portraits of soviet leader joseph stalin and russian revolutionary vladimir lenin as the russian communist party rallies to mark the centenary of the 1917 bolshevik revolution.
Overthrowing the conventional image of stalin as an uneducated political administrator inexplicably transformed into a pathological killer, robert service reveals a more complex and fascinating story behind this notorious twentiethcentury figure. Stalin acquired his books in various ways, including by borrowing them from other libraries and not returning them. Feb 01, 2019 a woman is flanked by portraits of soviet leader joseph stalin and russian revolutionary vladimir lenin as the russian communist party rallies to mark the centenary of the 1917 bolshevik revolution. During the soviet era, five separate editions of lenin s published works were published in russian, the first beginning in 1920 and the last from 1958 to 1965. Although lenin regarded trotsky and stalin as his two most able henchmen, trotsky diffidently rejected lenins attempts to play him against stalin. The main use of books in the soviet union was to imbed cultural products into the collective memory of the people. Oct 12, 20 for years after nikita khruschevs famous secret speech in 1956 denouncing stalin and some of his crimes, apologists for the ussr and its communist system continued to claim that if only lenin had lived longer, sovietstyle communism would have evolved in a much more benign direction than it ultimately did under the bloodthirsty stalin. A book on stalin by trotsky would be an event under any circumstances. In 1956 the lenin library asked for the return of 72 such books. While stalin ruled for almost three decades and was the successor of lenin, it was lenin who remains the father figure and a creator of modern day communist ussr which ended in 1990 though. Wolfe, theamerican mercury trotsky shows conclusively that soviet historiography has become an arsenal of falsifications constructed to defend. Trotsky is quick to point out the difference between lenin and stalin, saying of lenin, the idea of making a fetish of the political machine was not only alien but repugnant to his nature. He was a guiding force, navigating the regime through civil war, economic dislocation and famine, though at great cost.
Parallel lives, by the british historian alan bullock, published in 1992, is the best and certainly. Trotskys attempts to attack stalin thereafter were largely unsuccessful. Stalin was placed inside the tomb, in an open coffin, under glass, near lenins body. In the second half of the twentieth century, americans were taught to see both nazi germany and the soviet union as the greatest of evils. Censorship of books in the soviet union from 19201940.
A bold new accounting of the great social and political upheavals that enveloped europe between 1914 and 1945from the russian revolution through the second world war. Stalin, hitler and the temptations of totalitarianism. Lenin s testament is the name given to a document purportedly dictated by vladimir lenin in the last weeks of 1922 and the first week of 1923. See all books authored by vladimir lenin, including the state and revolution, and imperialism. He read widely, including books in foreign languages. Hitler was worse, because his regime propagated the unprecedented horror of the holocaust, the attempt to eradicate an entire people on racial grounds. Ten minute history the decline and dissolution of the soviet union short documentary duration. Jan 27, 2011 in the second half of the twentieth century, americans were taught to see both nazi germany and the soviet union as the greatest of evils. Lenins testament is the name given to a document purportedly dictated by vladimir lenin in the last weeks of 1922 and the first week of 1923. Kotkin tracks the changing revolution, noting how stalin and the bolsheviks benefited from the disintegration of the old order. Joseph stalin, leader of the soviet union 18781953.
His great capacity in this key phase of leadership was graphically shown, among other major campaigns, by the partys great drive to carry through the first fiveyear plan. Feb 27, 2018 ten minute history the decline and dissolution of the soviet union short documentary duration. In the testament, lenin proposed changes to the structure of the soviet governing bodies. Drawing on unexplored archives and personal testimonies gathered from across russia and georgia, this is the first fullscale. The social oppression of toiling masses, their apparent complete helplessness before the blind forces of capitalism.
Long but highly readable, it is still a valuable standard 45 years after. When this plan became known internationally, it evoked a chorus of sneers from bourgeois. Stalins war on ukraine a vivid and rounded picture of lenin the man. Arguing that the tragedies endured by europe were inextricably linked through the. Under stalin s regime, lenin was actively portrayed as a close friend of stalin s who had supported stalin s bid to be the next soviet leader. Leon trotsky and joseph stalin were political rivals. At the beginning of soviet rule, lenin, stalin, and trotsky holed up in a former finishing school for girls where the headmistress was still living, even as they dismantled czarist russia. Stalinist policies and ideas that were developed in the soviet union included rapid industrialization, the theory of socialism in one country, a totalitarian state, collectivization of agriculture, a cult of personality and subordination of the interests of foreign. However, when it was found that 62 of these books contained stalins annotations other ways were found to compensate the lenin library for its losses. While marx and engels wrote detailed critiques of capitalism they could only suggest the bare outlines of what socialism as the order of society supplanting capitalism could be like lenin built on these ideas and the experience of the workingclass movement to develop notions of the ways in which a transitional regime based on the. Though stalin wields great enforcement powers, kotkin infers trotsky is the intellectual successor to lenin. Oct 19, 2017 lenin had only seven years in power while stalin had 30. After trotsky was ousted 1925 as commissar of war, stalin, now allied with nikolai bukharin, turned on kamenev and zinoviev. Learn about his younger years, his rise to power and his brutal reign that caused.
Stalin, volume i documents the personalities and circumstances of the preu. Difference between lenin and stalin compare the difference. Kennan and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. Helen rappaports top 10 books on lenin books the guardian. Stalinism is the means of governing and related policies implemented from 1927 to 1953 by joseph stalin 18781953. Joseph stalin 18781953 was the dictator of the union of soviet socialist republics ussr from 1929 to 1953. Michael karpovich, the new york times trotskys stalin is sometimes brilliant and at all points highly informative and revealing, bertram d. After vladimir lenin, the first soviet head of state, suffered a stroke in early 1923, trotsky and stalin engaged in a contest for power. His library was a working one, not for show, and included books that had been banned and by rivals. Communist russia under lenin under lenins leadership, the new soviet state faced critical challenges which threatened its survival. Lenin held that religion was a simply product of social oppression and economic exploitation.
His library was a working one, not for show, and included books. In lenin, stalin, and hitler, acclaimed historian robert gellately focuses on the dominant powers of the time, the soviet union and nazi germany, but also analyzes the catastrophe of those years in an effort to uncover its political and ideological nature. It traces the history of the russian revolution from its first phase, dominated by vladimir lenin, to the rise of the bureaucracy, and the thermidorian reaction or counterrevolution of joseph stalin and his persecution and purging of the revolutionist generation, i. Russia under lenin and stalin by andics, hellmut and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. Russia and the west under lenin and stalin by george f. Sep 28, 2010 lenin and stalin both had ideas of how books should be used in the soviet union and these ideas are contrary to how we perceive the use of books today. In lenin, stalin, and hitler, acclaimed historian robert gellately focuses on the dominant powers of the time, the soviet union and nazi germany, but also analyzes the catastrophe of those years. For years after nikita khruschevs famous secret speech in 1956 denouncing stalin and some of his crimes, apologists for the ussr and its communist system continued to claim that if only lenin had lived longer, sovietstyle communism would have evolved in a much more benign direction than it ultimately did under the bloodthirsty stalin. Sensing his impending death, he also gave criticism of bolshevik leaders zinoviev, kamenev, trotsky, bukharin, pyatakov and stalin. Wolfe, theamerican mercury trotsky shows conclusively that soviet historiography has become an. Stalins purge of the 1930s 1968, where marx went wrong 1970, lenin 1972, stalin. A fresh, powerful portrait of lenin, and just at the right time. Vladimir lenin books list of books by author vladimir lenin. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read lenin, stalin, and hitler.
397 441 1351 1169 707 579 1120 840 1343 831 678 456 757 348 1425 46 131 699 1064 1028 1057 1551 1602 240 938 721 1134 32 554 1560 784 1186 901 327 889 1322 376 875 1065 599 960 1324 1139